Desk rejection reasons
WebThe main reason for this decision is that these are “living documents”. As explained in our first Editors’ View on biochar, experimental approaches that were at the forefront of … A desk reject, also known as a desk rejection, is when your paper is turned down by a journal, prior to them sending it out for review. This type of rejection can feel very disappointing, but don’t get too down on yourself. There are steps you can take to avoid this.
Desk rejection reasons
Did you know?
WebMar 24, 2024 · Most papers submitted to a journal get desk rejected. There are myriad reasons for that - it's possible the flaws are stylistic, rather than rooted in the results. It may not be a good fit. There may be more compelling items in the queue. The editor may simply not share the opinion of the people who have emailed you. WebFeb 10, 2024 · Joona Räsänen. 1 year ago. Perhaps the only reason for desk rejection I can think of is that the paper is not interesting enough (based on the opinion of the editor reading it). And this means roughly that the paper is not in the subdiscipline that the editor has specialized herself. In the earlier post, Kauppinen suggest a few possible ...
WebJul 19, 2024 · Problems in methodology are often a cause for desk rejection. The methodology can be too simple, e.g. purely descriptive with only simple correlations to …
WebFeb 26, 2024 · The last reason for desk rejection involves my personal judgment. Some papers have what I consider to be an inappropriate or unethical focus. An example is a … WebSep 4, 2024 · The rejection reasons were "not novel", or "would be more suitable for a more specialized journal" – doodle man. Sep 3, 2024 at 18:58. 15. ... both sent "desk rejection" one saying "it was out of scope" and other one suggested couple other journals. I am not going to lie - "out of scope" is a bit the academic version of "it's not you, it's me ...
WebNov 15, 2024 · Technical flaws in the content of your manuscript can also lead to its rejection. Common technical flaws include discrepancy between the abstract and the …
WebNov 15, 2024 · Inflated results are another cause of rejection, and inflation of results is often detected during the peer review process. Falsification and inflation of results should be avoided. Non-adherence to scientific and writing ethics can … orc hatchetWebNov 1, 2024 · Common Reasons for Desk rejection: General reasons for desk rejection of articles such as being out of scope, having a regional focus, lacking novelty, lacking … orc harvey weinstein maskWebSep 3, 2024 · Types of rejections and the reasons for them . Manuscript rejections fall into two main categories: desk rejections and rejections after review. A desk rejection is a … orc hashish definitionWebMoore cites three reasons for journal ‘desk-rejection’. These represent the vast majority of prevalent short-comings among submissions that don’t even make it into review. Broadly speaking, they are as follows: Poor … orc hazard databaseWebUniversity of Kelaniya Although this is not universal, here's a simple analysis of the most common reasons for rejection without peer review, so-called “desk-rejection”: The manuscript... orc hashishWebThere can be lots of reasons for a desk rejection and it doesn't necessarily mean that you work is poor. Most of the time it can be as simple as your paper is a wrong fit for that journal. ... Desk-rejected three times for not fitting the scope (even though it very much did), and then transferred to a new open-access sub-journal to the much ... ipro buy onlineWebRejection was a common fate for manuscripts across the types of submission; figures ranged from 26.7% for viewpoint articles to 72.1% for review articles. The median time to desk rejection was 3 days, while the median time to post-peer-review rejection and post-editorial-re-review rejection was 42 days and 96 days, respectively. ipro business solutions